AI and robotics are sprinting towards replacing human labor. This fact is no longer a matter of debate. Any task that is marginally productive compared to today’s AI capabilities is nothing more than a piece of data to be collected and transformed into a repeatable process that renders the human useless tomorrow.

In a world where human labor cannot reliably produce income, especially against a backdrop of skyrocketing living costs, younger people are understandably concerned about where they will get money to live dignified lives.

Gambling offers a seductive escape: if you lose, you land back in roughly the same dire position, but if you win, you can make the money you need for a dignified life. It is not surprising that 26% of Gen Z investors surveyed by Betterment in 2026 treat sports betting as part of their long-term financial strategy.

The grim reality, of course, is that gambling with a negative edge means that the person seeking a better financial reality is handed the exact opposite outcome with very high certainty. On average, they simply lose whatever theoretical rent they are charged with each bet.

Globally, H2 Gambling Capital projects that annual gambling revenue will exceed $1 trillion by 2030.

The cleanest economic way to eliminate gambling harm is to push this rent towards zero. The Gambling 2.0 Initiative is largely dedicated to supporting that cause by recognizing that most gambling can be self-financed: a loss/gain by one gambler can be a gain/loss for every other gambler rather than a gain/loss for a third party “house.” The collective group of variance-seekers can lose an amount close to zero, at least for games that require zero expertise to price (i.e. games of chance), rather than losing vast sums collectively to external institutions/sharps.

Better odds are only the beginning

However, a pure economic rearrangement, especially left unsupervised, is nowhere sufficient to reduce the harm associated with gambling.

Kalshi’s conflict with state governments is highly illustrative of this fact. Although they facilitate a peer-to-sharp structure that can offer better economic pricing for consumers, their sluggishness to acknowledge the underlying activity as gambling, and take full account of the reality of the industry, has dealt them and their users a devastating blow.

Gambling is psychologically addictive, with consequences that cannot be captured by pure economic expectancy. For someone with a gambling disorder, self-regulation can become extremely difficult. Someone addicted to gambling will often gamble recklessly until they have nothing left, even if their median loss, under less extreme variance, is as close to zero as possible. A British survey found that 22% of respondents with high gambling-problem scores reported a lifetime suicide attempt.

It therefore falls to the state and the operator to police problematic gambling.

However, their respective incentives could not be further apart. While public welfare is solely the responsibility of the state, with the National Council on Problem Gambling estimating $14 billion in annual U.S. social costs from criminal justice and healthcare spending, job loss, bankruptcy, and other consequences, the operator is not impacted whatsoever by the public cost of gambling. For the operator, higher player losses imply more gross gaming revenue for them, before expenses. Therefore, although licensed operators offer nominal oversight, the fact that their revenue equals their player’s losses means that enforcement is overwhelmingly negligible in practice.

Modern regulatory infrastructure

Thus the state needs to have as much power as possible. A sufficiently resourced state has every reason to identify and stop problem gamblers, without interfering with general freedom insofar as gambling can be done harmlessly and in a tax-generating way.

The core bottleneck for regulators, of course, is regulatory infrastructure. In today’s antiquated and fragmented system, regulators are highly removed from the “action.” A unified database of users, with deposits/bets/withdrawals/KYC tracked instantaneously, with the ability to immediately intervene, would INDISPUTABLY be the best way to prevent gambling from becoming problematic. (By the way, those details can also be anonymized unless an emergency requires deanonymization.)

The times we’re living in urgently call for this arrangement to be implemented. In addition to modernizing the regulatory infrastructure, it’s crucial that more, not fewer, forms of gambling are brought into the system, and that rents per bet are driven as low as possible via competition. Americans do not necessarily want to lose $53.9 billion a year to illegal and unregulated gambling (the AGA’s 2025 estimate, including offshore sites and unregulated machines), but if they have no better option onshore, they will, and once again they’ll fall out of the purview of the state tasked with protecting them.

In light of this, it is startling that platforms like Kalshi have decided not to voluntarily leverage their numerous technological and economic advantages to position themselves favorably with state governments. There is nothing about a national exchange that prohibits states from being able to intervene on matters of public safety, which is the spirit of all gambling intervention. Being a national exchange instead of a brick-and-mortar casino actually helps enable both oversight powers and revenue sharing. It certainly does not confer the right to advertise in predatory ways, which states have every right to be incensed over.

Unless you, my dear reader, do your part in sharing and furthering these ideas, this writing will likely not reach the correct audience. However, activism in this direction is extraordinarily important. We are on the brink of real economic disaster. If you do try to argue in favor of this first-principles approach to reducing harm, you will be shocked to see the opposition you meet.

The case against protectionism

Politicians ranging from Chris Christie to Ro Khanna are vehemently opposed to sports prediction markets. It is not a partisan issue: it is at best a lack of education, imagination or understanding of capitalism. At worst, it is a matter of extreme corruption. Nobody appears to be more outraged over “consumer protection” and “tax revenue generation” than the casinos themselves. On the former point, they’ve proven themselves woefully incapable of mitigating broad public harm (which has been true since well before the popularization of prediction markets). As for the argument that they’re better positioned to support state revenues, tax receipts alone do not settle that argument.

If their prices were more competitive than that of prediction markets, they would simply post those bids and asks on exchanges and collect revenue to their heart’s desire. Since this is obviously not the case (hence the whining), their request to their states is essentially “let us extract more than necessary from our consumers, and we’ll split the extra money with you.” Many would call this theft. Asking the states to participate in this buffoonery with a straight face is unconscionable. Commercial gaming generated $17.86 billion in direct state and local gaming taxes in 2025, but those receipts do not establish that the industry minimizes harm or deserves protection from competition. Tax revenue and estimated social costs measure different things; they are not a like-for-like balance sheet.

As a first priority, we should be focused on taking advantage of improvements in technology to lower prices to consumers and enact even more powerful protections to ensure gambling ruins as few lives as possible. Prediction markets in their current form fall short, but we should be extremely wary of knee-jerk lawfare that responds to poor implementation rather than poor fundamental design. Enshrining state gambling monopolies, when prediction markets have the potential to offer better prices and better holistic consumer protection, would be an absolute disaster and would set the world back at the very moment when it matters most.


A fourth principle for Gambling 2.0

In the same spirit, the Gambling 2.0 Initiative is declaring a new tenet. The new list of requirements that must be provably met for an exchange to qualify as Gambling 2.0:

  1. Nobody can seize any customer’s funds
  2. Nobody can control any bet’s outcome
  3. Only the public provides liquidity for bets
  4. Regulators have full transparency and protective control over their citizens

In consideration of the real risks of gambling addiction, any financial variance system that operates outside governmental supervision/intervention is doing so to the detriment of the citizens of that government. Since harm reduction is at the core of the Gambling 2.0 Initiative, it is only right that advances in technology also benefit the players as well as the governments responsible for their oversight. Although prediction markets can’t guarantee 2) and 3), the G2 Initiative nonetheless encourages prediction exchanges to voluntarily trailblaze a similar route by building modernized regulatory infrastructure and localizing compliance and atomic fee-sharing alongside Variance, the upcoming prototypical Gambling 2.0 exchange.

Sources and notes

  1. Betterment. 2026 Retail Investor Survey

    An online survey of 1,000 U.S. investors, conducted March 27–April 3, 2026. The 26% figure describes the Gen Z investor subgroup, not all young people.

  2. H2 Gambling Capital. Global gambling market forecast, April 2026

    Projects $1.031 trillion in gross gambling revenue in 2030. This is a forecast of operator revenue after payouts, not total amounts wagered or net profit.

  3. New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement. Cease-and-desist letter to Kalshi, March 27, 2025

    Documents New Jersey’s challenge to Kalshi’s sports contracts. The letter states the regulator’s legal position; it is not a final judgment resolving the federal–state dispute.

  4. National Centre for Social Research. Gambling behaviour, suicidality, and treatment and support

    Published January 2026, using an October 2024 survey of 11,646 people who gambled in Great Britain. Among respondents with PGSI scores of 8 or more, 22% reported a suicide attempt during their lifetime. This is not a suicide death rate.

  5. National Council on Problem Gambling. National social cost of problem gambling

    Estimates $14 billion per year, applying a formula from the 1999 National Gambling Impact Study Commission with inflation and adult-population adjustments through December 2023. It is an estimate across U.S. problem gambling, not a current measurement attributable solely to commercial casinos.

  6. American Gaming Association. 2025 illegal and unregulated gambling market analysis

    The $53.9 billion annual estimate comprises $18.6 billion from illegal online casino games, $5 billion from illegal sports betting, and $30.3 billion from unregulated machines. Operator revenue represents wagers less payouts, not the total volume wagered.

  7. American Gaming Association / CNBC. Chris Christie on sports event contracts

    Christie’s interview addresses sports contracts, state oversight, and consumer protection. Shared by the AGA in July 2026.

  8. Ro Khanna. Public statement on sports prediction markets, November 18, 2026

    Khanna called for investigation and a ban on sports prediction markets. The statement is linked as evidence of his position, not as a source for the article’s statistical estimates.

  9. American Gaming Association. State of the States 2026

    Reports $17.86 billion in direct state and local gaming taxes from commercial gaming in 2025. Excludes other corporate, income, sales and payroll taxes, and federal sports-wagering excise tax. This has a different scope from NCPG’s social-cost estimate.